Bay Shore New York Car Rentals
Let us help you find the best rental car options in Bay Shore, NY. Use RoadsideAmerica.com to make an online reservation with a Bay Shore, New York rental car agency after you select from a range of rental car companies, vehicle types, and rates. You can compare your rental car choices and options in Bay Shore, New York by filling in the form below. Select the vehicle that's right for you, and it will be waiting for you when you arrive.
To view cities close to Bay Shore, NY also offering car rentals, click here.
Islip, NY (1.86 miles)
West Islip, NY (2.50 miles)
Deer Park, NY (4.56 miles)
Central Islip, NY (4.74 miles)
West Babylon, NY (5.56 miles)
Lindenhurst, NY (6.93 miles)
Bohemia, NY (7.86 miles)
Commack, NY (8.17 miles)
Ronkonkoma, NY (8.74 miles)
Melville, NY (9.03 miles)
Smithtown, NY (9.17 miles)
Amityville, NY (9.38 miles)
Farmingdale, NY (10.06 miles)
Massapequa Park, NY (10.73 miles)
East Northport, NY (11.01 miles)
Huntington Station, NY (11.31 miles)
Saint James, NY (11.44 miles)
Centereach, NY (11.99 miles)
Patchogue, NY (12.57 miles)
Huntington, NY (13.21 miles)
Wantagh, NY (13.99 miles)
Syosset, NY (14.14 miles)
Hicksville, NY (14.33 miles)
Bellmore, NY (15.20 miles)
Smarter Car Renting
Here are car rental tips from the road trip-seasoned editors of RoadsideAmerica.com:
• Car Types: When selecting a car type, remember it's not just about how cool you'll appear. The car selection page details show an average of how many people and how many pieces of luggage can comfortably fit in each car type. Pay attention to the specifics to be certain they meet your needs before booking.
• Many States, One Car: If renting a car for a longer road trip, check with the car rental companies in Bay Shore, New York to see if they have policies about crossing state lines that affect the final rate you pay. May be no effect, but don't assume you can crisscross the globe with unlimited mileage impunity. There may be a GPS tracker in the car!
• Credit Cards for Pick-Up: Many agencies require a credit card upon pick-up. Yes, Opie, we live in that kind of world. So make sure you are in good standing with your "plastic." Call the car rental agency in Bay Shore before arrival or verify in the rental policy and rules to see which forms of payment they accept.
Click here to see Bay Shore attractions
Bay Shore NY Area Attractions
- Southside Hospital
- Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center (3.19 miles)
- Long Island University -Brentwood Campus (3.46 miles)
- Dowling College (5.87 miles)
- Memorial Sloan-Ketterin Cancer (6.89 miles)
- Nassau-Suffolk Hospital Shared (6.91 miles)
- Five Towns College (8.46 miles)
- Adventureland (8.99 miles)
- Brunswick General Hospital (9.22 miles)
- Walt Whitman Mall (10.64 miles)
- Smith Haven Mall (12.00 miles)
- Veterans Affairs Medical Center (12.16 miles)
- Brookhaven Memorial Hospital (14.74 miles)
- Nassau University Medical Center (15.83 miles)
- Yaphank Day Treatment Center (16.40 miles)
- SUNY College at Old Westbury (17.35 miles)
- Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum - New York Islanders (17.71 miles)
- Mall at The Source (17.95 miles)
Bay Shore rental guide
The following car rental companies are available in Bay Shore New York
Click on the logo to view the locations and average rates.
Enterprise Rent A Car
4205 Austin Blvd
22.37 miles from Bay Shore NY US
4205 Austin Blvd
22.37 miles from Bay Shore NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
3300 Long Beach Rd
21.43 miles from Bay Shore NY US
3300 Long Beach Rd
21.43 miles from Bay Shore NY US
Avis Rent A Car System, Inc.
55 Sunrise Highway
21.89 miles from Bay Shore NY US
55 Sunrise Highway
21.89 miles from Bay Shore NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
184 Merick Rd
22.56 miles from Bay Shore NY US
184 Merick Rd
22.56 miles from Bay Shore NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
602 Sunrise Hwy
20.74 miles from Bay Shore NY US
602 Sunrise Hwy
20.74 miles from Bay Shore NY US
Hertz Corporation
56 Horton Avenue
23.31 miles from Bay Shore NY US
56 Horton Avenue
23.31 miles from Bay Shore NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
2900 Merrick Rd
14.64 miles from Bay Shore NY US
2900 Merrick Rd
14.64 miles from Bay Shore NY US
Hertz Corporation
3288 Merrick Road
14.13 miles from Bay Shore NY US
3288 Merrick Road
14.13 miles from Bay Shore NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
300 W Merrick Rd
24.21 miles from Bay Shore NY US
300 W Merrick Rd
24.21 miles from Bay Shore NY US
Gas Cost From 4205 Austin Blvd Island Park To Bay Shore
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.20
- Standard SUV: $4.26
- Compact Car: $3.34
- Economy Car: $3.20
- Standard Car: $3.65
- Full-Size Car: $3.84
- Mid-Size Car: $3.34
- Premium Car: $3.84
- Luxury Car: $4.04
- Mini Van: $4.04
Gas Cost From 3300 Long Beach Rd Oceanside To Bay Shore
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.06
- Standard SUV: $4.08
- Compact Car: $3.20
- Economy Car: $3.06
- Standard Car: $3.50
- Full-Size Car: $3.68
- Mid-Size Car: $3.20
- Premium Car: $3.68
- Luxury Car: $3.87
- Mini Van: $3.87
Gas Cost From 55 Sunrise Highway Lynbrook To Bay Shore
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.13
- Standard SUV: $4.17
- Compact Car: $3.27
- Economy Car: $3.13
- Standard Car: $3.58
- Full-Size Car: $3.75
- Mid-Size Car: $3.41
- Premium Car: $3.75
- Luxury Car: $3.95
- Mini Van: $3.95
Gas Cost From 184 Merick Rd Lynbrook To Bay Shore
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.22
- Standard SUV: $4.30
- Compact Car: $3.36
- Economy Car: $3.22
- Standard Car: $3.69
- Full-Size Car: $3.87
- Mid-Size Car: $3.36
- Premium Car: $3.87
- Luxury Car: $4.07
- Mini Van: $4.07
Gas Cost From 602 Sunrise Hwy Rockville Centre To Bay Shore
Close - Standard Convertible: $2.96
- Standard SUV: $3.95
- Compact Car: $3.09
- Economy Car: $2.96
- Standard Car: $3.39
- Full-Size Car: $3.56
- Mid-Size Car: $3.09
- Premium Car: $3.56
- Luxury Car: $3.74
- Mini Van: $3.74
Gas Cost From 56 Horton Avenue Lynbrook To Bay Shore
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.48
- Standard SUV: $4.44
- Compact Car: $3.48
- Economy Car: $3.48
- Standard Car: $3.63
- Full-Size Car: $4.00
- Mid-Size Car: $3.81
- Premium Car: $4.21
- Luxury Car: $4.21
- Mini Van: $4.70
Gas Cost From 2900 Merrick Rd Bellmore To Bay Shore
Close - Standard Convertible: $2.09
- Standard SUV: $2.79
- Compact Car: $2.18
- Economy Car: $2.09
- Standard Car: $2.39
- Full-Size Car: $2.51
- Mid-Size Car: $2.18
- Premium Car: $2.51
- Luxury Car: $2.64
- Mini Van: $2.64
Gas Cost From 3288 Merrick Road Wantagh To Bay Shore
Close - Standard Convertible: $2.11
- Standard SUV: $2.69
- Compact Car: $2.11
- Economy Car: $2.11
- Standard Car: $2.20
- Full-Size Car: $2.42
- Mid-Size Car: $2.31
- Premium Car: $2.55
- Luxury Car: $2.55
- Mini Van: $2.85
Gas Cost From 300 W Merrick Rd Valley Stream To Bay Shore
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.46
- Standard SUV: $4.61
- Compact Car: $3.61
- Economy Car: $3.46
- Standard Car: $3.95
- Full-Size Car: $4.15
- Mid-Size Car: $3.61
- Premium Car: $4.15
- Luxury Car: $4.37
- Mini Van: $4.37
Are you already happy with the services of a specific rental car company? Then skip the others -- you can use the form above to peruse the vehicle options and rates of one brand if available in Bay Shore, NY. Reminder: enter in your discount or reward number at check-out when you rent your car in Bay Shore, NY.
