Montauk New York Car Rentals
It's easy to find rental car options in Montauk, NY when you let RoadsideAmerica.com help! You can make an online reservation with a Montauk, New York rental car agency after you select from a range of rental car companies, vehicle types, and rates. Compare your rental car options in Montauk, New York by filling in the form below with your desired dates and other information. Pick the vehicle that's right for you, your passengers and your activities, whether it's a road trip or a business mission.
To view cities close to Montauk, NY also offering car rentals, click here.
East Hampton, NY (14.09 miles)
Mystic, CT (21.77 miles)
Groton, CT (22.15 miles)
Watermill, NY (22.36 miles)
New London, CT (23.11 miles)
Westerly, RI (24.21 miles)
Southampton, NY (25.51 miles)
Cutchogue, NY (27.33 miles)
Old Saybrook, CT (28.28 miles)
Westbrook, CT (32.15 miles)
Norwich, CT (34.28 miles)
Narragansett Pier, RI (36.91 miles)
Madison, CT (37.65 miles)
Riverhead, NY (37.90 miles)
Westhampton Beach, NY (39.66 miles)
Guilford, CT (41.57 miles)
Colchester, CT (42.11 miles)
North Kingstown, RI (43.37 miles)
Newport, RI (45.44 miles)
Branford, CT (48.02 miles)
Willimantic, CT (48.71 miles)
Middletown, RI (48.96 miles)
Shirley, NY (50.91 miles)
West Warwick, RI (51.11 miles)
Smarter Car Renting
Here are car rental tips from the road trip-seasoned editors of RoadsideAmerica.com:
• Damaged: Always carefully eyeball your vehicle before leaving the rental agency, whether you're in Montauk or East Podunkville. The last renter may have pulled in after a meteor shower! Prior scratches, dents, and other vehicle damage can cause extra headaches and costs if not noted before you leave the rental car lot. If you see any damage on the car's exterior and interior before you leave, make sure it's noted on the rental car papers, and point it out to an agency employee. This will resolve any questions that could arise when you return. And avoid meteor showers.
• Special Requests: Special requests can be noted at the time you make your Montauk rental car reservation. Nothing too crazy, though. If you are in need of an infant or toddler car seat, navigation system, ski rack or more, be sure to make note of it when booking online. Keep in mind that requests are not guaranteed and additional fees may apply.
• Car Types: When selecting a car type, remember it's not just about how cool you'll appear. The car selection page details show an average of how many people and how many pieces of luggage can comfortably fit in each car type. Pay attention to the specifics to be certain they meet your needs before booking.
Click here to see Montauk attractions
Montauk NY Area Attractions
- Mitchell College (21.40 miles)
- Lawrence & Memorial Hospital (22.15 miles)
- Pequotsepos Nature Center (22.45 miles)
- Denison Homestead (22.45 miles)
- Mystic Aquarium (23.12 miles)
- US Coast Guard Academy (24.32 miles)
- Lyman Allyn Art Museum (24.46 miles)
- Connecticut College (24.87 miles)
- Crystal Mall (25.32 miles)
- Wickham's Fruit Farm (27.92 miles)
- Mashantucket Pequot Museum (29.20 miles)
- Long Island University - Southampton College (29.22 miles)
- Water Wizz (31.66 miles)
- Enchanted Forest (33.57 miles)
- Hammonasset State Park (34.87 miles)
- Backus Hospital (35.32 miles)
- William W Backus Hospital (35.62 miles)
- Chamard Vineyards (35.63 miles)
Montauk rental guide
The following car rental companies are available in Montauk New York
Click on the logo to view the locations and average rates.
Avis Rent A Car System, Inc.
59 Maple Street
25.01 miles from Montauk NY US
59 Maple Street
25.01 miles from Montauk NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
395 County Rd
25.57 miles from Montauk NY US
395 County Rd
25.57 miles from Montauk NY US
Hertz Corporation
1640 Montauk Highway
21.41 miles from Montauk NY US
1640 Montauk Highway
21.41 miles from Montauk NY US
National Car Rental System, Inc.
434 Boston Post Rd
28.67 miles from Montauk NY US
434 Boston Post Rd
28.67 miles from Montauk NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
434 Boston Post Rd
28.67 miles from Montauk NY US
434 Boston Post Rd
28.67 miles from Montauk NY US
Avis Rent A Car System, Inc.
155 Tower Rd
21.07 miles from Montauk NY US
155 Tower Rd
21.07 miles from Montauk NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
42 Williams Ave
21.53 miles from Montauk NY US
42 Williams Ave
21.53 miles from Montauk NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
453 Colman Street
23.99 miles from Montauk NY US
453 Colman Street
23.99 miles from Montauk NY US
Enterprise Rent A Car
13 East Avenue
23.69 miles from Montauk NY US
13 East Avenue
23.69 miles from Montauk NY US
Gas Cost From 59 Maple Street Southampton To Montauk
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.57
- Standard SUV: $4.77
- Compact Car: $3.73
- Economy Car: $3.57
- Standard Car: $4.09
- Full-Size Car: $4.29
- Mid-Size Car: $3.90
- Premium Car: $4.29
- Luxury Car: $4.52
- Mini Van: $4.52
Gas Cost From 395 County Rd Southampton To Montauk
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.65
- Standard SUV: $4.87
- Compact Car: $3.81
- Economy Car: $3.65
- Standard Car: $4.18
- Full-Size Car: $4.39
- Mid-Size Car: $3.81
- Premium Car: $4.39
- Luxury Car: $4.62
- Mini Van: $4.62
Gas Cost From 1640 Montauk Highway Watermill To Montauk
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.19
- Standard SUV: $4.08
- Compact Car: $3.19
- Economy Car: $3.19
- Standard Car: $3.34
- Full-Size Car: $3.67
- Mid-Size Car: $3.50
- Premium Car: $3.86
- Luxury Car: $3.86
- Mini Van: $4.32
Gas Cost From 434 Boston Post Rd Old Saybrook To Montauk
Close - Standard Convertible: $4.10
- Standard SUV: $5.46
- Compact Car: $4.28
- Economy Car: $4.10
- Standard Car: $4.68
- Full-Size Car: $4.92
- Mid-Size Car: $4.47
- Premium Car: $4.92
- Luxury Car: $5.18
- Mini Van: $5.18
Gas Cost From 434 Boston Post Rd Old Saybrook To Montauk
Close - Standard Convertible: $4.10
- Standard SUV: $5.46
- Compact Car: $4.28
- Economy Car: $4.10
- Standard Car: $4.68
- Full-Size Car: $4.92
- Mid-Size Car: $4.28
- Premium Car: $4.92
- Luxury Car: $5.18
- Mini Van: $5.18
Gas Cost From 155 Tower Rd Groton To Montauk
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.01
- Standard SUV: $4.02
- Compact Car: $3.14
- Economy Car: $3.01
- Standard Car: $3.44
- Full-Size Car: $3.61
- Mid-Size Car: $3.29
- Premium Car: $3.61
- Luxury Car: $3.80
- Mini Van: $3.80
Gas Cost From 42 Williams Ave Mystic To Montauk
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.08
- Standard SUV: $4.10
- Compact Car: $3.21
- Economy Car: $3.08
- Standard Car: $3.52
- Full-Size Car: $3.69
- Mid-Size Car: $3.21
- Premium Car: $3.69
- Luxury Car: $3.89
- Mini Van: $3.89
Gas Cost From 453 Colman Street New London To Montauk
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.43
- Standard SUV: $4.57
- Compact Car: $3.58
- Economy Car: $3.43
- Standard Car: $3.92
- Full-Size Car: $4.12
- Mid-Size Car: $3.58
- Premium Car: $4.12
- Luxury Car: $4.33
- Mini Van: $4.33
Gas Cost From 13 East Avenue Westerly To Montauk
Close - Standard Convertible: $3.39
- Standard SUV: $4.51
- Compact Car: $3.53
- Economy Car: $3.39
- Standard Car: $3.87
- Full-Size Car: $4.06
- Mid-Size Car: $3.53
- Premium Car: $4.06
- Luxury Car: $4.28
- Mini Van: $4.28
Are you already happy with the services of a specific rental car company? Then skip the others -- you can use the form above to peruse the vehicle options and rates of one brand if available in Montauk, NY. Reminder: enter in your discount or reward number at check-out when you rent your car in Montauk, NY.
