Unloved Statue of President McKinley
President William McKinley's statue survived an earthquake in San Francisco -- but it remains to be seen if it will survive another century in Arcata.
The eight-foot-tall bronze statue was a gift to the city from local businessman George Zehnder. Famous sculptor Haig Patigian created a blocky, big-headed version of the 25th President that looks a little like Elektro the Robot (who, like McKinley, was born in Ohio). Patigan had the sculpture commission completed and in a San Francisco foundry when the Great San Francisco Earthquake struck on April, 18, 1906. Zehnder hustled south, and in the still-smoldering devastation he managed to recover the McKinley and took it to Arcata.
For most of its life in the center of Arcata, the McKinley statue was loved, and the populace enjoyed close interactions -- dressing it for the holidays or placing items in his hand or around his neck. But these days he skews to the unloved end of the spectrum, because McKinley was an imperialist -- and many of the town's current resident college students aren't majoring in imperialism. The statue has been the subject of petitions to demand its removal, and has repeatedly been dressed in humiliating outfits. When vandals stuffed McKinley's nose and ears with cheese, it was national news.
One grayish, Pacific coast morning, we were the only ones in the park taking notice of the centrally positioned imperialist. The picturesque palm trees might cause an observer to remember McKinley's grab of islands from the Hawaiian people, or his annexation of lands after the Spanish American war. The statue seems to be on a high enough perch to discourage casual defacers (whose unkempt hair and backpack straps might fatally entangle on his outstretched hand). McKinley!