Elmsford, New York: Muffler Man: Paul Bunyan

Fiberglass Paul Bunyan. One-armed, the stump hidden behind the sign. Then the other arm was gone; since replaced.

Address:: N Saw Mill River Rd, Elmsford, NY
Directions:: On Saw Mill River Rd. just north of the exit ramp off of I-287 Exit 2. From the east, cross the Cross Tappan Zee Bridge, pay the toll, then immediately take the first exit (#9) onto US 119. At the bottom of the exit ramp, make a right at the light, then make a quick right at the gas stations onto White Plains Rd. Drive for a mile, pass the Eldorado Diner on the left. At the second light past the Eldorado, make a left, cross back under I-287 and the MM is on the left.
Phone:: 914-347-8252
RA Rates:: Worth a Detour

The Muffler Men Map

Muffler Men: Find more like this in our roadside roundup map of The Muffler Men

Results 1 to 5 of 10... Page of 2 [Next 5 items]

Visitor Tips and News About Muffler Man: Paul Bunyan

Reports and tips from RoadsideAmerica.com visitors and Roadside America mobile tipsters. Some tips may not be verified. Submit your own tip.

Muffler Man Paul Bunyan.

Muffler Man Paul Bunyan

Contrary to previous reports, the Elmsford one-armed Paul Bunyan Muffler Man is still standing at his post at the BP station on Saw Mill River Road.

[Evan Robinson, 10/03/2025]

Muffler Man - Paul Bunyan

We were just at this BP and the muffler man is no longer there. Not sure when or where he went.

[Cathi, 07/14/2025]

BP Bunyan.

Muffler Man - Paul Bunyan

Nothing new, he looks awesome!

[sam, 05/13/2024]

Gas prices may fluctuate, but the gaze of the burly BP Bunyan remains steady.

BP Muffler Man.

BP Paul Bunyan

The one-armed Paul Bunyan in BP livery looked down on our charter bus -- we were returning from Salem, Massachusetts, to Kentucky -- as we sat for eight hours, broken-down and blocking the pumps, on Halloween Day 2021. You can't make this stuff up.

[Ben Kelley, 11/18/2021]

Muffler Man.