Middletown, Pennsylvania: Jeremiah Crow's Creepy Collection of Curiosities (Closed)

Edgar the Alligator Man and Jo Jo the Dog Face Boy are two of many sideshow gaffs and non-living oddities in a small museum of freaks.

Directions:: Inside Saturday's Market. Take the Toll House Rd exit off Interstate 283. Make a right onto Route 230. The Market is impossible to miss. Less than a mile from the exit.
Status:: Closed

Results 1 to 2 of 2...

Visitor Tips and News About Jeremiah Crow's Creepy Collection of Curiosities

Reports and tips from RoadsideAmerica.com visitors and Roadside America mobile tipsters. Some tips may not be verified. Submit your own tip.

Alligator Man poster.

Jeremiah Crow's Creepy Collection of Curiosities

Just stopped by. The collection is closing this week, with no known future address.

[Jennifer Kefer, 11/18/2019]

The collection was also formerly at the Gettysburg Dime Museum. It will rise again, somewhere.

Ball O Ties.

Jeremiah Crow's Creepy Collection of Curiosities

Located in Saturday's Market is a small curiosities museum showcasing a generous collection of sideshow gaffs and oddities including "Edgar the Alligator Man," "Jo Jo the Dog Face Boy," and "The Headless Mummy who found Conan O'Brien's Head." The gift shop has many odd collectibles for sale.

[Jeremy Crowther, 07/24/2019]

These freakish exhibits were formerly part of the impressive Gettysburg Dime Museum. Curator Mark Kosh closed that place last year, so perhaps the monstrosities resurfaced under a new name.